Nathaniel Philbrick, Mayflower: A Story of Courage, Community and War(affiliate link). New York. Penguin Books, 2006. 463 pages.
I confess that even though I was a history major, I never spent much time learning about the founding of the United States. This book is helpful, informative, engaging, and thought provoking. Most people have an idealized understanding of the sailing of the Mayflower and the landing of the Pilgrims on Plymouth Rock. The true story is much more complex.
The Pilgrims faced numerous challenges simply getting to America. They were taken advantage of by unethical ship companies and captains. The voyage itself took 65 days (3). The only existing English colony at the time was Jamestown, which was founded in 1607 (5). The death rate in the early colonies was appalling. In Jamestown, 70 of 108 settlers died in the first year (5). Between 1619 and 1622, 3,600 people arrived in Jamestown. Tragically, 3,000 of them died. The Pilgrims faced similar challenges in Plymouth.
The Pilgrims were Puritans who had initially sought to purify the corrupt Church of England. When they realized they couldn’t achieve that goal, they became Separatists and formed their own church. Eventually, they became Pilgrims.
The Mayflower set sail on Sept. 16, 1620 (29). Only 50 members of the congregation were on board. And as so often happens in history, things didn’t go according to plan. The ship was aiming for the mouth of the Hudson River, but it ended up off the Massachusetts coast instead (33). On Nov. 9, after a harrowing Atlantic crossing, the settlers finally spotted land (34). They famously established the “Mayflower Compact” before going ashore (40). Forty-one men signed the visionary document, a covenant binding them to each other before God. Within four months, half the signers were dead (46).
The Norman Rockwell–type portrayals of the first Thanksgiving don’t adequately convey how grim the first years were in Plymouth. A plague, perhaps the bubonic plague, had devastated the coastline between 1616 and 1619 (48). Though the coast had previously teemed with Native American settlements, they had largely been lost due to the plague. The Pilgrims didn’t know how to survive in the harsh wilderness. Fortunately, they befriended Massasoit, chief of the Pokanokets tribe (48). The Pilgrims eventually celebrated the first Thanksgiving with him and 100 of his people. Philbrick suggests that the first Thanksgiving probably took place in late September or early October (117). He notes that “the Pilgrims proved to be more receptive to the new ways of the New World than nearly any English settler before or since” (64).
A second colony was later established at Wessagussett. It consisted of a rougher crowd of colonists, including many single men (140).
The Pilgrims could be vicious, although they generally followed the standard of the times. They would decapitate enemies and mount their heads on the palisade posts. They were also prepared to hang, draw, and quarter particularly notorious renegades. John Robinson, their spiritual leader who never reached America, said, “Oh, how happy a thing had it been . . . if you had converted some before you had killed any” (156). The Pilgrims, though they made alliances with many indigenous people, converted few.
The original settlers had forged a workable relationship with Native American tribes, but the second generation of Pilgrims was less inclined to cooperate with them. Alexander, the son of Massasoit, became chief. White men arrested him on a spurious charge, and he died in custody (202). His brother Philip took his place. Philip saw himself as equal to King Charles II of England (202). As a result, when war broke out, it was called “King Philip’s War.”
During the 14-month conflict, Plymouth Colony lost 8% of its men. Of the roughly 20,000 indigenous people in that area, 2,000 were killed in battle, 3,000 died of sickness and starvation, 1,000 were sold as slaves, and 2,000 fled to safer regions (332). Philip was eventually killed, and his head was left on display at the Plymouth fort for two decades (338).
In 1692, Plymouth became a part of the Massachusetts Colony (346). Philbrick claims that “the Pilgrims’ religious beliefs played a dominant role in the decades ahead, but it was their deepening relationship with the Indians that turned them into Americans” (347). He concludes, “For peace and for survival, others must be accommodated. The moment any of them gave up on the difficult work of living with their neighbors—and all of the compromise, frustration, and delay that inevitably entailed—they risked losing everything. It was a lesson that Bradford and Massasoit had learned over the course of more than three long decades. That it could be so quickly forgotten by their children remains a lesson for us today” (348).
I found this book to be interesting. Clearly, the Pilgrim myths taught to schoolchildren gloss over many struggles, crimes, and embarrassing events. The life of the Pilgrims was cruel and harsh. They found themselves in a desperate fight for survival. Their religious beliefs gave them the grit to endure enormous suffering and deprivation. Out of desperation, they learned to work with indigenous tribes. But the next generation soon became greedy for land, and they relinquished many of the morals their parents had tried to instill in them. War appears to have been inevitable.
Philbrick is evenhanded in his treatment of history. He doesn’t gloss over gross injustices inflicted by the English, nor does he portray all Native Americans as noble. He lets history speak for itself and avoids sermonizing, which would have been easy to do.
If you’ve never read much about the Mayflower or the Pilgrims, I recommend this book!
Rating: 3

Leave a Reply